When to Restore vs. Replace Your Piano – Making the Right Choice

A Common Question Among Piano Owners

If your piano has lost its tone, responsiveness, or beauty, you might be wondering — is it worth restoring, or should you replace it altogether? The answer depends on the piano’s age, brand, structure, and sentimental value. At STRAND Piano Repairs & Tuning, we’ve guided Edmonton families, musicians, and institutions through this decision for over 28 years.

When Restoration Is the Best Option

Restoration is often worthwhile when: The piano was built by a high-quality manufacturer like Steinway, Yamaha, or Bösendorfer. The instrument has a solid structural foundation (intact frame and soundboard). It holds sentimental or historical value — such as a family heirloom or antique. You want to preserve authentic craftsmanship and unique tone quality.

A full restoration can revive tone, touch, and aesthetics, often resulting in a piano that plays better than new and retains long-term value.

When Replacement Might Make Sense

In some cases, replacement may be the more practical route: The piano’s pinblock or soundboard is severely compromised. It was an entry-level model with limited long-term potential. Restoration costs exceed the instrument’s resale or musical value.

Our technician will provide a transparent, no-pressure assessment — helping you compare the cost, longevity, and performance benefits of both options before you decide.

Why Choose STRAND Piano Repairs & Tuning

With hands-on experience restoring instruments from the 1800s to modern grands, we combine technical insight with integrity. Whether we restore your cherished piano or guide you toward a replacement, our goal is always the same — ensuring you enjoy the best possible instrument for your needs.

Book a Piano Evaluation Today

Before deciding, get a professional opinion from Edmonton’s trusted piano specialist.

Schedule a piano inspection today.